PROTEST BY MR. ALDERMAN COTTON.
To The Queen's Most Excellent Majesty.
Protest against report.
May it please Your Majesty,
Being unable to agree with the report of the Commissioners appointed by
Your Majesty to investigate the affairs of the Livery Companies of the City of London,
I beg most humbly to be allowed to present to Your Majesty a protest against the same,
upon the following grounds.
No evidence against Companies.
1. That no evidence has been produced against the honour, honesty, or integrity
of the Livery Companies; it is true that opinions have been expressed against them,
but no facts have been before the Commission which in any way affect their high
character, and the estimation in which they have always been deservedly held by the
Recommendations should be presented to the Companies as "suggestions" only.
2. Many opinions have been given to the Commission as to the manner in which
the funds of the Companies should be used. I think the purposes of this Commission
will be answered if their recommendations were presented to the Livery Companies as
"suggestions." This would make the Commission far more fruitful than any arbitrary
Act, as the Companies have always shown themselves ready to appreciate and to give
effect to any practicable suggestions tending to increase their public usefulness, and
would leave the management of the properties to those who thoroughly understand it.
The appointment of any new body or bodies must result in many blunders, much waste,
and much cost.
Parliamentary interference unnecessary in "restraint of alienation."
3. That the suggested interference by Parliament through the House of Lords, or
otherwise, in "restraint of alienation" must be unnecessary, as the experience of
centuries shows that no Company has ever contemplated or suggested the realisation
of its property for the purposes of dividend or division.
Livery franchise representative, and ought not to be abolished.
4. That the Parliamentary franchise enjoyed by liverymen is held by men, some of
humble and some of the highest position, thus forming a constituency as representative
as any in the realm. It numbers over 7,000 members, who obtain their privileges
irrespective of their political opinions. The abolition of the livery vote would not of
necessity disenfranchise the man, as the large majority have votes through other
holdings in addition to that given them by their livery, and as no one can enjoy two
votes, the one which they may use is decided by the revising barrister. Admission
to freedom only does not confer any Parliamentary Franchise.
Common Hall ought not to be abolished, uses set out.
5. The Common Hall is attended by the most active citizens, who take an interest
in municipal affairs, it annually selects two aldermen who are returned to the Court
of Aldermen to elect one as Lord Mayor, it also elects the sheriffs and some of the
high officers of the Corporation. Common Halls can also be called together to discuss
any question of public interest or emergency, and should not be abolished.
Interference by Parliament with Companies' private property spoliation.
6. That interference by Parliament with the private property of the Livery Companies
must be an act of oppression and spoliation, although disguised under the terms of
"restraint of alienation" or "allocated to the support of objects of acknowledged
public utility," and that no new Commission could possibly manage the affairs of the
Companies so successfully, usefully, or more honestly than the present members who
represent a long line of illustrious ancestors.
Public audits not justifiable.
7. That no public audit or other outside interference with the private accounts of
the property of the Companies is necessary or justifiable, the lands and the properties
of the Companies having been acquired either by purchase, the money for this purpose
being derived from the accumulations of fees paid by, or fines inflicted upon their
members, or by gifts and legacies, also from members of their own body.
Members of the Companies never were exclusively of craft
8. That the returns made to the Commission show conclusively that the members of
the Livery Companies were never exclusively of the trade the name of which was
borne by their Company, and that for about 400 years the larger proportion of the
members have not pretended to follow the crafts of their Companies, hence any forced
devolution of their funds in aid of such trades would be a gross injustice. It cannot
be pretended that any Company was established solely to promote the interest of the
trade whose name it bears.
Description of what the Companies really are.
9. The Livery Companies are not to be classed with friendly or benevolent societies,
with monastic institutions, or with political or other clubs. They are institutions
peculiar to themselves, approaching most nearly to the masonic body, being composed
always of members of the highest honour. They are and always have been foremost in
promoting education, charitable and kindly acts, and other worthy eleemosynary objects.
It is only possible to become a member of a Livery Company by patrimony, by
apprenticeship, or by redemption (which last means by purchase or gift). Redemption
is allowed by vote of the Court only after strict investigation as to the character and
position of the applicant. Freemen and liverymen, even if they become members at
the age of 21 years, would not be placed upon the Court in some Companies for at least
15 years, and in the majority for a much longer period. They are only admitted on
payment of a large fine and after a second investigation as before. The average
duration of the life of members in the Court is 12 to 14 years, during which time and
for this period of their life only they enjoy the full advantages of the Company. To
attain this position and to serve the offices of wardens and master is the ambition
of all men connected with any Company, and I unhesitately affirm that the Livery
Companies have exercised in the past, and do in the present, a very good and important
moral influence not only upon citizens and city life, but upon public life generally.
As to income and expenditure.
10. The available annual corporate or non-trust income of the Livery Companies,
without taking any allowance in respect of halls and other buildings used by the
Company, or the plate, furniture, and other property not producing income, may fairly
be estimated at about 510,000l. This sum is to be enjoyed by about 7,000 liverymen
and 13,000 freemen, who in time, when qualified, become liverymen, making a total
of about 20,000. Their annual expenditure may be estimated as follows:—
|50,000||1. The statistics prove that the Livery Companies
require no recommendation from the Commission to
promote this. The suggestions therefore of those
who have appeared before it are simply unnecessary
and superfluous in this respect.|
|2. Eleemosynary gifts,
|30,000||2. These, notwithstanding the ideas expressed by
a few persons to the contrary, cannot tend to pauperise the recipients; on the contrary, they are productive of great comfort, chiefly helping those who
are absolutely reduced by a sudden or great calamity,
and who, but for the aid thus rendered, would become paupers. Beyond this the charities of the
Companies, joined to other private and individual
charity, tend to maintain the peace of the nation by
helping those who cannot help themselves, while
saving their self respect, and also assist the rates by
keeping a large number from applying for parochial
aid. These remarks apply equally to pensions.
Assistance is never given to other than really
deserving cases, and then only after full inquiry.|
|3. Hospitals and general charity|
|70,000||3. These donations speak for themselves, and are
an invaluable benefit to the institutions to whom
grants are made. Without the aid of the Companies
many of the Metropolitan hospitals, benevolent and
charitable institutions would have to seriously curtail
their usefulness, and probably some might have to
close their doors. The amount spent for general
charity goes in support of an immense variety of
objects—poor boxes of the Metropolitan police courts,
homes, refuges, orphan asylums, hospitals, missionary
societies of all denominations, all the Mansion House
funds, gardens and recreation grounds for the people,
scientific objects, &c.|
|4. Salaries, wages, &c.|
|60,000||4. These are not excessive, when the qualifications
required by the holders of the offices and the
character of the work done are considered. Before
men are appointed to an office in any Company they
are subjected to a strict examination as to their
capacities and integrity. There are always many
candidates who are subjected to a severe contest,
and have to win an election before appointment, the
most efficient being always selected. The Clerk is
the only high salaried officer in every Company.|
|75,000||5. The hospitalities of the Livery Companies
do much good by bringing all classes together
who otherwise in these days of suburban residence
would never meet. At all dinners the guests, not
members, far exceed those belonging to the Company, frequently including Royalty and the distinguished men of the day. In addition to this, the
livery and their friends enjoy one or more dinners
per annum, according to the custom and position of
the Company to which they belong.|
|40,000||6. The annual fees paid to individual members of
the Livery Companies (which represent this total)
are paid only for actual attendance and in consideration of the time spent in the transaction of
the affairs of the Company, which varies from one
to five or more hours. These fees do not amount
in any Company to more, and in some to less than
those given by Bank, Insurance, Co-operative, and
other trading Companies for the same or even less
services. Dividends are entirely unknown.|
|7. Rates and taxes|
|30,000||7. This completely refutes the statement that the
Livery Companies do not contribute some share
towards the State and local government expenses.|
|8. Rents of almshouses
household expenses, and expenses in relation
|75,000||8. The household expenses are by no means
excessive. The other items are reasonable and
necessary and productive of great good.|
|9. Sums expended in
Ulster in support
of churches and
schools of all
|10,000||9. This requires no comment.|
|10. Improvement of
estates in England
|70,000||10. These are necessary to maintain the properties
and work of the Companies, and no objection can
reasonably be made thereto. It must also be borne
in mind that the position of the halls in their
different localities has tended to improve and maintain the respectability of the district in which they
Number of members of court not important.
11. It cannot be of any real importance whether the Courts of the Livery Companies
be composed of 10, 20, 30, or 40 members, when their surroundings and social positions
are considered. It must be remembered that every liveryman aspires to attain the
Court of his Company, and that to enable a fair proportion of the livery to do this, it
is absolutely necessary that the Courts be large in number. It may also be pointed
out that each member has paid a sum according to the status of his Company for his
seat, and that he does not reach this till he is far advanced in life, that some die before
and some soon after their election on the Court before they have received even a return
of the fines and fees paid by them to their Company.
Colourable apprenticeship no wrong.
12. What is called colourable apprenticeship is no wrong, it being one of the modes
of admission, and enables a man of moderate means to obtain for his son a position in
the Company, which otherwise he would not have been able to do, and which may be
to his advantage in after life. It must be remembered that this has been the custom of
Charitable and trust estates under control of Charity Commission.
13. The administrative control of charitable and all trust estates has long since
passed away from the Livery Companies, and they are only now administered by them
under the order and approval of the Charity Commissioners at cost and trouble to
themselves, and undoubted advantage to the trusts.
As to interest of all members in property of Company.
14. It is true that only 1,500 of the livery out of a total of about 20,000 liverymen
and freemen are members of the Courts of the Companies at any one time, but each
qualified liveryman and freeman in rotation, if life allowed, would become a member.
The whole of the remaining 18,500 members have a vested interest in the properties
of the Companies, and enjoy advantages and privileges as such. There is no evidence
and not even a suggestion of any contemplated payment of any dividend or any
misappropriation or division of the funds, and nothing of the sort could legally take
place without the consent of each and every member, be he liveryman or be he freeman.
Members of Companies are satisfied with present administration.
15. The present administration may be said to be in almost thorough accord with
the feelings of every member of the Companies; the only two adverse opinions given
before the Commission were contradictory, one being of opinion that his Company
did too much, the other that his did too little.
Liverymen do not pay annual subscription.
16. It has been stated that the liverymen only pay 1l. a year for their privileges.
They do not pay any annual subscription (except quarterage in some Companies, which
amounts from a few pence to a few shillings per annum), but each pays down on
admission sums varying from 150l. to 200l. in the more important, and from 15l. to 50l.
in the lesser Companies, for which he practically receives no return until he is admitted
on the Court, when a further sum of from 25l. to 250l., according to the position of the
Company, has to be paid. All admissions being very carefully made as stated in
paragraph 9 of this protest, it follows that but very few are admitted in any one
year, and thus the united payments for admission may only amount on an average to
the sum mentioned. I beg to enter a most emphatic protest against the partisan spirit
which has prompted the publication of misleading statements.
Summary of the position of Companies.
17. Finally, I respectfully submit to Your Majesty that the Livery Companies are
middle-class institutions, and have always been well, honourably, and honestly
managed; (against this assertion no evidence has been adduced) and any attempt to
destroy them will seriously affect the middle class of the City of London and the
Metropolis, and, possibly, hereafter, through them, the whole of this class throughout
the realm; it would be one more advance towards centralization, which, if established,
will ultimately divide the people of this country into two classes, the highest and
the lowest, or aristocracy and serf; a state of affairs which, by preventing union in a
common cause, led to the subjection of Poland to Russia. That they pay all rates,
taxes, &c. ordinarily paid by landlords and tenants, including income tax on all moneys
annually received by them. That the pensions, gratuities, and doles, which are
curiously objected to by some parties, as previously stated, save the rates, by keeping
the recipients from applying for parochial relief, as by so doing they would forfeit all
claim to any gift from their Company. Almost every object brought before the
Commission as worthy of being assisted from or through the funds of the Livery
Companies, such as education (general and technical), hospitals, public playgrounds,
accidents of moment, in short, everything that charity, philosophic, or scientific bodies
can suggest, has from time to time been profusely assisted by the Livery Companies.
Their income, as stated in paragraph 10 of this protest, may be estimated at 510,000l.
per annum, out of which under 35 per cent, is spent on the members, including in this
amount 60,000l. for salaries, wages, &c., a position which I humbly venture to think very
few bodies of men in similar circumstances could improve, leaving 335,000l., of which
70,000l. is applied towards the improvement of estates in England and Ireland, and in
the maintenance of halls, &c., 30,000l. in payment of rates, taxes, &c. the balance being
applied in supporting good, useful, and charitable objects. That the agitation against
the Livery Companies is but small, and must be so as their work, constitution, and uses
must be seen, felt, and known to be appreciated, and this every man in the kingdom
can now do upon a reference to their returns. To upset the existing order of things
by the appointment of new and most probably more expensive bodies of management,
would, independently of the great injustice done to the rights of property, produce,
as very many pretended reforms in the past have done, no better, and most likely
far worse results. No public bodies of importance (not even those who appeared
before the Commission) have advocated or sought for a distribution of the properties
of the Companies. They have very naturally expressed a hope that they might, in
the event of any distribution, be allowed to share, in order that what they must lose
under the altered position of the Livery Companies, might, in some way be made
good. The Livery Companies have no money in hand, the whole of their balances
being applied, as has been previously shown, to works of acknowledged public utility
and goodness. The Charity Commission have in all cases reported most favourably
of the Companies, showing that they are most excellent trustees, who spend a much
larger amount than they are bound to do on all the charities they administer; and I
would also humbly beg to call Your Majesty's gracious attention to the fact that nearly
all important civil actions attacking the private properties of the Companies have been
decided in their favour. Any interference with the property of the Livery Companies
must tend to create mistrust and destroy confidence in all benefit and other societies
which tend to inculcate habits of saving and thrift.
Much has been said about the power of the Parliament to take possession of the
properties of the Livery Companies. I do not doubt its power but I do its right to
commit a gross injustice and wrong.
Attention called to protest of Companies.
18. Lastly, may it please Your Majesty to allow me humbly to call your gracious
attention to the protest against the abstraction of the private properties of the Livery
Companies which accompanied each return to the Commission.
(Signed) W. J. R. COTTON.
April 10th, 1884.